If Donald Trump were Mexican, would he still be Donald Trump? The problem of identity in counterfactuals and a dispositionalist solution

Giulia Casini

Giulia Casini

Keywords: , counterfactuals, possible worlds, identity, dispositions, potentiality, properties

Abstract

The study of counterfactuals has produced some well-known problems concerning identity. I focus on two of them. I suggest that a dispositionalist account of counterfactuals, not involving possible worlds but dispositions and potentiality, could solve both. First is the problem of identity across possible worlds, concerning the identification of individuals in various possible worlds. Dispositionalism can solve it: its aim is to explain counterfactuals in the actual world, without appealing to possible worlds. This would eliminate the problem because the individuals involved in counterfactuals would be in the actual world, without needing identification in other worlds. Second is the problem of what I call ‘property alteration’. In ‘if Donald Trump were Mexican, he wouldn’t be President of the USA’, denying Trump’s property of ‘being a US citizen’ could lead us to deny the identity between the Donald Trump we know and the Donald Trump of the counterfactual. Barbara Vetter’s version of dispositionalism can solve also this problem, introducing the concept of ‘potentiality’.

References

Borghini, Andrea and Williams, Neil E. (2008), «A Dispositional Theory of Possibility», in Dialectica, vol. 62, n. 1 (March 2008), pp. 21-41.

Kripke, Saul (1971), «Identity and Necessity», in Munitz Milton, Identity and Individuation, New York University Press, New York, pp. 135-64.

Kripke, Saul (1980), Naming and Necessity, Blackwell, Oxford 1990.

Lewis, David (1968), «Counterpart Theory and Quantified Modal Logic», in Journal of Philosophy, vol. 65 n. 5 (March 1968), pp. 113-26.

Lewis, David (1973), Counterfactuals, Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford 2001.

Lewis, David (1986), On the Plurality of Worlds, Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford 2001.

Manley, David and Wasserman, Ryan (2008), «On Linking Dispositions and Conditionals», in Mind, vol. 117, n. 465 (January 2008), pp. 59-84.

Martin, Charlie B. (1994), «Dispositions and Conditionals», in The Philosophical Quarterly, vol. 44, n. 174 (January 1994), pp. 1-8.

Noonan, Harold and Curtis, Ben (2018), «Identity», in Zalta Edward N., The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2018 Edition), from: https://plato.stanford.edu/ archives/sum2018/entries/identity/.

Stalnaker, Robert (1968), «A Theory of Conditionals» in Rescher Nicholas, Studies in Logical Theory, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 98-112.

Stalnaker, Robert (1975), «Indicative Conditionals» in Philosophia, vol. 5, n. 3 (July 1975), pp. 269-286.

Vetter, Barbara (2011), «Recent Work: Modality without Possible Worlds», in Analysis Reviews, vol. 71, n. 4 (October 2011), pp. 742-754.

Vetter, Barbara (2014), «Dispositions without conditionals», in Mind, vol. 123, n. 489 (January 2014), pp. 129-156.

Vetter, Barbara (2015), Potentiality: from Disposition to Modality, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Vetter, Barbara (2016), «Counterpossibles (not only) for dispositionalists», in Philosophical Studies, vol. 173, n. 10 (October 2016), pp 2681-2700.