The real significance of metaphor: Lucian Blaga and Michael Polanyi

  • Richard T. Allen
Keywords: Attending from-to, Lucian Blaga, plus knowledge, minus knowledge, plastic metaphors, revelatory metaphors, Michael Polanyi, Piaget, tacit integration

Abstract

Metaphors are taken to be ‘figures of speech’ which apply the terms for one known object to another. They can be used to show or argue that what applies to the one also applies to the second. But this ignores the Lucian Blaga’s important distinction between such ‘plastic’ metaphors and ‘revelatory’ ones which articulate for both the discoverer and for his audience something radically new for which there is no word. This relies upon our tacit powers, as shown by Piaget and articulated by Michael Polanyi, to adapt our present concepts, categories and language by using them as clues and attending from them and to what we sense that they point to and which cannot be ‘assimilated’ to them. A completely new word would articulate and convey nothing, but a word used as a revelatory metaphor can both open up a ‘mystery’ or ‘unknown unknown’ and reveal and convey something of it. The work of Blaga, Polanyi and Piaget on epistemology and language is used to explain, with examples, how this is possible and why it is important. Indeed, language grows by means of such metaphors which, if successful, then become ‘literal’ uses of the words used, and their metaphorical origins are forgotten. The proper understanding of metaphor may require some radical changes in our ideas of language and knowledge.

References

BLAGA, Lucian (1933), Cunoasterea Luciferica, Tiparul Institutului de Arte Grafice “Dacia Traiana”, Sibiu.

BLAGA, Lucian (1937), Geneza Metaforei si Sensul Culturii, Fundatia pentru Literatura si Arta, Bucarest.

BLAGA, Lucian (1942), Stiinti si Creatie (Science and Creation), Dacia Traiana, Sibiu.

BLAGA, Lucian (2017), Lucian Blaga: Selected philosophical extracts, eds., BOTEZ Angela, ALLEN, R. T., SERBAN, Henrieta A., Vernon Press, Wilmington DE.

COLLINGWOOD, R. George (1938), The Principles of Art, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1958.

COLLINGWOOD, R. George (1940), Essay on Metaphysics, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1998.

JONES, Michael S. (2006), The Metaphysics of Religion: Lucian Blaga and Contemporary Philosophy, Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, Madison NJ.

KORNER, Stefan (1970), Categorial Frameworks, Blackwell, Oxford.

LIDDELL, Henry, SCOTT, Robert (1871), Greek-English Lexicon Abridged, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1958.

MARCEL, Gabriel (1935), Être et avoir, Aubier, Éditions Montaigne, Paris (Being and Having, trans. Kathleen Farrar, Dacre Press, London 1949).

WITTGENSTEIN, Ludwig (1921), Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Routledge, London 1981.

PIAGET, Jean (1947), La psychologie de l’intelligence, A. Colin, Paris (Psychology of Intelligence, trans. Piercy Malcom and Berlyne D. E., Routledge, London 2001).

PIAGET, Jean (1973), La construction du réel chez l’enfant, Delachaux et Niestlé, Neuchâtel, Paris (The Child’s Conception of the World, trans. Tomlinson J. Tomilson A., Paladin, London 1973).

POLANYI, Michael (1958), Personal Knowledge, Routledge, London.

POLANY, Michael (1975), Meaning, University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London.

Sitography

Online Etymology Dictionary, etymonline.com

Published
2017-12-03
How to Cite
Allen, R. T. (2017) “The real significance of metaphor: Lucian Blaga and Michael Polanyi”, Rivista Italiana di Filosofia del Linguaggio, 11(2). Available at: http://rifl.unical.it/index.php/rifl/article/view/436 (Accessed: 8December2024).