La mente rituale. Dalla nascita del rito all’origine delle istituzioni umane
Abstract
In this paper we make reference to the debate about the nature, the evolution and the mechanisms underlying social rituals from a naturalistic point of view. Considering current observations coming from the phylogenetic perspective, we explore two prevailing and opposite accounts of the ritual dimension which characterizes social groups: on the one hand, a non-adaptationist approach argues that ritual is essentially “derivative”, that is, represents a dysfunctional by-product of cognitive adaptations arisen for other purposes; by contrast, the adaptationist model claims that ritualistic actions have a specific value for social cooperation and, hence, are part of an evolutive line tied to socially adaptative behaviors. Consistent with the latter account, we examine the specific hypothesis that the development of complex human rituals has been fostered by the emotional components tied to ritualization involved in collective animal practices. To this extent, we argue that emotionally-charged rituals have played a crucial role in the origin and the evolution of social constraints underlying the articulated human institutions.
References
ADORNETTI, Ines, FERRETTI, Francesco (2013), «By-product, exaptation e nicchie culturali. Un modello adattativo della religione», in Sistemi intelligenti, n. 25 (2), pp. 339-358.
ALCORTA, Candace, SOSIS, Richard (2005), «Ritual, emotion, and sacred symbols», in Human nature, n. 16(4), pp. 323-359.
ALCORTA, Candace, SOSIS, Richard (2010), «Signals and Rituals of Humans and Animals», in Marc Bekoff [a cura di] Encyclopedia of Animal Rights and Animal Welfare, Greenwood Publishers, Westport, CT, pp. 519-523.
ANASTASI, Matthew W., NEWBERG, Andrew B. (2008), «A preliminary study of the acute effects of religious ritual on anxiety», in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, n. 14(2), pp. 163-165.
AURELI, Filippo, de WAAL, Fransiscus B.M. (2000), Natural Conflict Resolution, University of California Press.
AURELI, Filippo, PRESTON, Stephanie D., de WAAL, Fransiscus B.M. (1999), «Heart rate responses to social interactions in free-moving rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta): a pilot study», in Journal of Comp. Psychology, n. 113, pp. 59-65.
BARRETT, Justin (2007), «Cognitive science of religion: What is it and why is it? », in Religion Compass, n. 1, pp. 768-786.
BERING, Jesse M. (2006), «The folk psychology of souls», in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, n. 29 (05), pp. 453-462.
BLOOM, Paul (2007), «Religion is natural», in Developmental science, n. 10 (1), pp. 147-151.
BOYER, Pascal (2001), Religion explained, New York, Basic Books; trad. it. E l’uomo creò gli dei, Odoya, Bologna, 2010.
BOYER, Pascal, LIÉNARD, Pierre (2006), «Precaution systems and ritualized behavior», in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, n. 29(06), pp. 635-641.
CORDS, Marina (1992), «Post-conflict reunions and reconciliation in long-tailed macaques», in Animal Behaviour, n. 44, pp. 57-61.
CORDS, Marina (1997), «Friendships, alliances, reciprocity and repair», in A. WHITEN & R.W. BYRNE [a cura di] Machiavellian intelligence II: extensions and evaluations, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
BULBULIA, Joseph (2008), «Meme infection or religious niche construction? An adaptationist alternative to the cultural maladaptationist hypothesis», in Method & theory in Study religion, n. 20, pp. 67-107.
D’AQUILI, Eugene, NEWBERG, Andrew B. (1999), The mystical mind: Probing the biology of religious experience, Fortress Press.
DAVIS, M.H. (1994) Empathy: A Social Psychological Approach, Brown and Benchmark, Madison WI.
DENNETT, Daniel (2006), Breaking the spell: religion as a natural phenomenon, New York, Viking; trad. it. Rompere l’incantesimo, Milano, Raffaello Cortina 2007.
De WAAL, Fransiscus B.M., LANTING, Frans (1997), Bonobo: The Forgotten Ape, University of California Press.
DUNBAR, R.I.M. (1991), «Functional significance of social grooming in primates», in Folia Primatologica, n. 57, pp. 121-131.
DUNBAR, Robin I.M. (1998), «The social brain hypothesis», in Evolutionary Anthropology, n. 6, pp. 178-190.
FERRETTI, Francesco, ADORNETTI, Ines (in stampa), «Biology, culture, and coevolution: religion and language as case studies», in Journal of Cognition and Culture.
FISCHER, Ronald, CALLANDER, Rohan, REDDISH, Paul, BULBULIA, Joseph (2013), «How Do Rituals Affect Cooperation? An Experimental Field Study Comparing Nine Ritual Types», in Human Nature, n. 24, pp. 115-125.
GINTIS, Herbert, SMITH, Eric A., BOWLES, Samuel (2001), «Costly signaling and cooperation», in Journal of theoretical biology, n. 213 (1), pp. 103-119.
HUMMER, Robert A., ROGERS, Richard G., NAM, Charles B., ELLISON, Christopher G. (1999), «Religious involvement and US adult mortality», in Demography, n. 36 (2), pp. 273-285.
IRONS, William (2001), «Religion as a hard-to-fake sign of commitment», in R. NESSE (a cura di), Evolution and the capacity for commitment, Russell Sage, New York, pp. 292-309.
LEE, Bruce Y., NEWBERG, Andrew B. (2005), «Religion and health: a review and critical analysis», in Zygon, n. 40(2), pp. 443-468.
LEVENSON, Robert W. (2003), «Autonomic specificity and emotion», in R.J. Davidson, K.R. Scherer & H.H. Goldsmith [a cura di] Handbook of affective sciences, Oxford University Press, New York.
LEVIN, Jeffrey S., SCHILLER, Preston L. (1987), «Is there a religious factor in health? », in Journal of Religion and Health, n. 26, pp. 9-36.
LIENARD, Pierre, BOYER, Pascal (2006), «Whence collective rituals? A cultural selection model of ritualized behavior», in American Anthropologist, n. 108(4), pp. 814-827.
MASSON, Jeffrey M., McCARTHY, Susan (1995), When Elephants Weep: The Emotional Lives of Animals, Bantam Doubleday Dell, New York; trad. it. Quando gli elefanti piangono. Sentimenti ed emozioni nella vita degli animali, Baldini e Castoldi Dalai 1996.
MITHEN, Steven J. (2006), «The evolution of social information transmission in Homo», in J.C.K. WELLS, S.S. STRICKLAND & K. LALAND [a cura di] Social Information Transmission and Human Biology, CRC Press, London, pp. 151-170.
NEWBERG, Andrew B., ALAVI, Abass, BAIME, Michael, POURDEHNAD, Michael, SANTANNA, Jill, D’AQUILI, Eugene (2001), «The measurement of regional cerebral RIFL / SFL 2013
POWELL, Russell, CLARKE, Steve (2012), «Religion as an evolutionary byproduct: A critique of the standard model», in British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, n. 63, pp.457-486.
RAPPAPORT, Roy A. (1999), Ritual and Religion in the Making of Humanity (Vol. 110), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
RICHERSON, Peter J., BOYD, Robert (2005), Not by genes alone: How culture transformed human evolution, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
RICHERSON, Peter J., NEWSON, Lesley (2008), «Is religion adaptive? Yes, no, neutral, but mostly, we don’t know», in J. BULBULIA, r. SOSIS, e. HARRIS, r. GENET, c. GENET & K. [a cura di] The evolution of religion. Studies, theories & critiques, Collins Foundation Press, Santa Margarita, CA, pp. 73-78.
ROSSANO, Matt J. (2009), «Ritual behaviour and the origins of modern cognition», in Cambridge Archaeological Journal, n. 19(2), p. 243-56.
ROSSANO, Matt J. (2012), «The essential role of ritual in the transmission and reinforcement of social norms», in Psychological Bulletin, n. 138, pp. 529-549.
ROUGHGARDEN, J. (2004), Evolution's Rainbow: Diversity. Gender, and Sexuality in Nature and People, Berkeley ua.
ROWE, Candy (1999), «Receiver Psychology and the Evolution of Multi-Component Signals», in Animal Behaviour, n. 58, pp. 921-931.
SAPOLSKY, Robert M. (1999), «Hormonal Correlates of Personality and Social Contexts: From Non-human to Human Primates», in C. PANTER-BRICK & C. WORTHMAN [a cura di] Hormones, Health and Behavior, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 18-46.
SOSIS, Richard (2009), «The Adaptationist-Byproduct debate on the evolution of religion: Five misunderstandings of the adaptationist program», in Journal of Cognition and Culture, n. 9, pp. 315-322.
SOSIS, Richard, ALCORTA, Candace (2003), «Signaling, solidarity, and the sacred: The evolution of religious behavior», in Evolutionary anthropology: issues, news, and reviews, n.12(6), pp. 264-274.
SOSIS, Richard, BRESSLER, Eric R. (2003), «Cooperation and commune longevity: A test of the costly signaling theory of religion», in Cross-Cultural Research, n. 37, pp. 211-239.
SPERBER, Dan (1996), «Explaining culture: A naturalistic approach», Blackwell, Oxford; trad. it. «Il contagio delle idee», Feltrinelli , Milano, 1999.
TURNER, Robert P., LUKOFF, David, BARNHOUSE, Ruth T., LU, Francis G. (1995), «Religious or Spiritual Problem. A Culturally Sensitive Diagnostic Category in the DSMIV», in Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, n. 183, pp. 435-444.
VIRNO, Paolo (2010), E così via, all'infinito: logica e antropologia, Bollati Boringhieri.
Works published in RIFL are released under Creative Commons Licence:Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
